Row as only one woman on panel

First published in News

SIX people have been appointed to head up a new watchdog for councillors in Worcestershire – but only one is a woman and none are from ethnic minorities.

The make-up of Worcestershire County Council ’s standards regime has sparked a furious row, with some politicians calling for the entire project to be scrapped and started afresh.

Under new Government legislation bosses at County Hall were tasked with finding six random members of the public to scrutinise any complaints made about councillors.

But the roles, which are unpaid, have attracted just one woman and the list features a completely white panel.

Councillor Richard Udall said: “Nothing against those who are on the list, but as soon as I looked at this alarm bells were ringing in my head.

“Where are the ethnic minorities? And where are the women? There’s one token female to complete the list.

“This is simply not good enough. This panel is supposed to represent people across all sections of the community.

“We need to actually wake up, go out there and find people who truly represent everyone in Worcestershire. It’s time to re-advertise the positions and start again.”

Coun Peter McDonald, Labour group leader, said: “It’s pathetic – a terrible job has been done.”

Under the Localism Act, six ‘independent persons’ needed to be found to be the first port of call for any complaints made against politicians.

They are to look at each complaint and act as advisoers in terms of deciding if the councillor needs to be reprimanded.

The positions were advertised and they only attracted applications from 11 people.

A report on it, which was debated during a recent full council meeting, says all six live in Worcestershire and are “independent of party politics”.

It includes David Coulson, a former police inspector, James Hipkiss, an ex-independent councillor at Wyre Forest District Council, and Catherine Mangan, who used to work in local government and is a senior fellow at the University of Birmingham.

Magistrate Raymond Needham, barrister David Warner and Fred Noble, another former independent councillor in Wyre Forest, are also there.

Coun Adrian Hardman, the county council’s leader, said: “The fact is, anybody could have put their name forward and we would have welcomed their application.

“It was advertised and we’re happy with the list. “If Labour wanted different people on it, they should have tried harder.”

Comments (2)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

2:52pm Thu 27 Sep 12

badge73 says...

why does it have to be so many from each sex or ethnic minorities? many years ago it was thought ... the best person for the job. now its every minority you can think of .... thanks labour!!
why does it have to be so many from each sex or ethnic minorities? many years ago it was thought ... the best person for the job. now its every minority you can think of .... thanks labour!! badge73
  • Score: 0

9:11am Fri 28 Sep 12

Kieron's left foot says...

Even Brezhnev would have blushed at such a selection process...I'm thinning of running for mayor . I'm in with a great chance. No experience but im an obese buck toothed Geordie. I must be in with a chance. Lol
Even Brezhnev would have blushed at such a selection process...I'm thinning of running for mayor . I'm in with a great chance. No experience but im an obese buck toothed Geordie. I must be in with a chance. Lol Kieron's left foot
  • Score: 0

Comments are closed on this article.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree